Video studio 11 audio not rendered (XVID)

Moderator: Ken Berry

Post Reply
keveen

Video studio 11 audio not rendered (XVID)

Post by keveen »

Hello,

My source video is recorded by my Samsung DIGIMAX i6 which records video as an avi file coded as XVID Mpeg4 file at 30fps. The audio is mpeg (mp1/mp2) (0x0050) Microsoft Corporation according to Gspot.

The video clips play back fine on the timeline but when I render them using the default mpeg2 format there is no sound. If I try to use the "Same as first video clip" setting I get an error message:
Unable to access the audio codec driver.
If I use the basic Windows Movie Maker that comes with Windows XP the audio on the exported video file is correct.

I'm guessing that Video Studio is not picking up one of Microsoft's codecs??

Seems daft that I have to revert back to the basic Windows video editing program to do the job!

Is there a fix otherwise the program is useless even though the rest of it seems superb!
DVDDoug
Moderator
Posts: 2714
Joined: Sun Jan 23, 2005 12:50 am
Location: Silicon Valley

Post by DVDDoug »

...as an avi file coded as XVID Mpeg4 file...
:( You are not alone... All of the highly compressed formats seem to cause lots of trouble. :(
The audio is mpeg (mp1/mp2)...
Video Studio can usually handle MPEG-2 audio. ...I'm not sure about MPEG-1 audio. Maybe it's just having trouble because it's multiplexed into an Xvid file... :?
If I use the basic Windows Movie Maker that comes with Windows XP the audio on the exported video file is correct.... Is there a fix otherwise the program is useless...
If you are planning of doing lots of Xvid editing, you are probably better-off staying with Movie Maker, or looking for a special-purpose Xvid editor.* (In fact, I use a special-purpose MPEG-2 editor.)

...A couple of things you can try with SUPER (a FREE universal-conversion program):

Use SUPER to convert your AVI/Xvid to a WAV file (audio only). Bring that WAV file into Video Studio and use it as your soundtrack. (Consult the Video Studio User Manual for details.)

Or, use SUPER to convert the AVI/Xvid to MPEG-2 with MPEG-2 audio. If you are doing any editing, you will want to keep the audio & video together in the same file. But, I will pre-warn you that even MPEG-2 can sometimes cause trouble too. :(


* Note - Even with a special-purpose editor, none of these compressed formats were originally designed to be edited or converted. They all use lossy compression, which means that data is thrown-away (and quality/detail is lost) during compression.

When professional DVDs are made, all editing is done with uncompressed files (or with film). MPEG-2 compression is is done as (almost) the last step!

Most "real editing" (transitions, text-overlays, cropping, color adjustment, etc.) requires the file to be de-compressed and re-compressed. You loose quality with the 2nd compression.

When you convert from one compressed format to another, this also requires an extra (lossy) compression step.
[size=92][i]Head over heels,
No time to think.
It's like the whole world's
Out of... sync.[/i]
- Head Over Heels, The Go-Gos.[/size]
keveen

Post by keveen »

Thanks for your comprehensive reply. I'd never heard of Super - I'll give it a try.

The best mpeg-2 editor I have ever used is Womble Video Wizard but unfortunately that too fails to recognise the audio. All I really wanted to do was to join the clips together for this batch to upload onto Google videos. Ulead should perhaps look at why XPs basic editor does the job? What has it got that Videostudio does not? What is the missing link! :shock:

It's really annoying when sophisticated tools like Videostudio can't do simple jobs! When it does work it is excellent.
Post Reply